Research & evidence
The history of trigger point research, from 1942 to today
How Janet Travell's wartime clinical observations became referred pain maps, a two-volume manual and, eventually, a contested research field.
Published:
Where the maps came from
The referred pain patterns used across this site descend from a specific clinical practice: injecting procaine into tender muscular spots and recording exactly where the patient's pain disappeared from. Travell's 1942 JAMA paper on shoulder and arm pain describes that method and the surprising finding that pressing one small point in a muscle reproduced pain several segments away.
Over the following decades those case series were consolidated into the pattern drawings that clinicians still recognise — a shaded 'essential' zone where nearly every patient feels pain, plus a stippled 'spillover' zone that appears in more irritable cases.
From clinical description to laboratory question
The manual that grew out of this work is a description of what clinicians observed, not a mechanistic proof. Reviews written since have been explicit about that distinction: the patterns proved clinically useful and reproducible enough to teach, while the explanation for why a nodule in a taut band refers pain elsewhere remained open.
That gap is what turned trigger points into a research field rather than a purely clinical craft — first through electrophysiology and needle EMG work, then through biochemistry and imaging.
How to read the old literature today
Treat the historical work as a well-tested map of where symptoms tend to come from, and the modern work as the ongoing argument about mechanism. The practical implication for a clinician is unchanged: the pattern narrows the search, palpation that reproduces the patient's familiar pain confirms relevance, and the response to treatment settles it.
Every muscle page on this site follows exactly that sequence, which is why the historical maps and current evidence are cited side by side rather than as competing sources.
Studies cited
Every claim in this article traces back to one of the sources below.
- Travell 1942 — Pain and disability of the shoulder and arm: treatment by intramuscular infiltration with procaine hydrochloride. JAMA 1942;120(6):417-22 ↗
- Simons & Travell — Myofascial Pain and Dysfunction: The Trigger Point Manual (2nd ed.). Williams & Wilkins, Baltimore ↗
- Shah 2015 — Myofascial trigger points then and now: a historical and scientific perspective. PM R 2015;7(7):746-61 ↗
- Simons 2004 — Review of enigmatic myofascial trigger points as a common cause of enigmatic musculoskeletal pain and dysfunction. J Electromyogr Kinesiol 2004;14(1):95-107 ↗

